Does a gas or oil furnace chimney need to be swept or inspected?
Updated · KeystoneProGuide editorial team
Does a furnace chimney need attention if you never light a fire?
Yes. A chimney that serves a furnace, boiler or water heater is working every day of the heating season, and the agencies that deal with carbon monoxide all put it on the yearly list. The Environmental Protection Agency says to have a trained professional inspect, clean and tune up the central heating system annually, and spells out what that means: furnaces, flues and chimneys. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says to have the chimney checked or cleaned every year.
The trade agrees, as you would expect. Asked whether a chimney should be checked when the house heats with gas, its certification body, CSIA, answers that it should, and says to schedule annual inspections for all your chimneys, gas furnaces included.
Inspection is the yearly part. Whether the flue also needs sweeping depends on the fuel and on what the inspection finds.
Why would a gas flue need checking when gas burns clean?
Because soot is not the main problem. CSIA gives three reasons.
- Blockage. A gas flue can stop working because of bird nests or other debris. The Consumer Product Safety Commission makes the same point: birds, other animals and insects can build nests in vents over spring and summer, sending exhaust into the house.
- Corrosion. CSIA says today's high-efficiency gas furnaces produce fumes with high levels of water vapor, and that the vapor picks up chlorides from household air, so flues face more corrosive conditions than before. Clay liner tiles can flake off under those conditions, and the flakes can block the flue.
- Mismatch. Modern furnaces, CSIA says, can have many problems when vented through flues built for older ones.
Do not rely on the furnace to protect you. The Commission notes that furnaces are built with shut-off devices against a blocked vent, but says the improvements in modern furnaces do not guard against every condition that can lead to carbon monoxide exposure.
What is different about an oil furnace or boiler?
Oil leaves soot. CSIA says an oil flue should be inspected annually because deposits build up on the inner wall of the liner, and that excessive soot can cause chimney fires, damage the flue and create blockages that send fumes back into the house and make the furnace run inefficiently.
Oil is also hard on the liner. The Better Business Bureau notes that an oil-burning furnace produces sulfur oxides and that over time sulfur eats at the chimney liner, which can crack.
Soot is what a sweep removes, so with oil the yearly inspection is more likely to end in a cleaning. Fixr puts the cost of cleaning an oil or gas furnace chimney at about $125 to $400, lower than for a wood-burning flue because there is no creosote, and says the time to do it is just before the heating season or directly after it.
What if the house was converted from oil to gas?
Then the chimney deserves particular care. The Commission addressed this in a 1990 release: chimney inspections are especially important where oil or coal heating has been converted to gas, because accumulated soot and debris left in the chimney could block the escape of carbon monoxide afterwards. Its advice was to have the chimney inspected at the time of the conversion and yearly thereafter, and to have it cleaned each year until no more soot is found.
CSIA adds the corrosion angle. Many gas appliances, it says, use chimneys that once served oil furnaces, and those are the clay liners that can flake.
Who checks the flue: the heating contractor or a chimney sweep?
Do not assume either one will unless you ask. This is the most useful sentence in the Commission's 1990 release: chimneys and flues are not normally checked by heating contractors, so consumers should ask them to include the venting system in the inspection.
What the check should cover is set out across the Commission's guidance:
- the chimney and flue, for blockages, corrosion, partial and complete disconnections and loose connections;
- flues and the connector pipes between appliance and chimney, for tight fittings and for signs of rust or cracks;
- the outside of the chimney, for black stains, which a 1997 release said can mean pollutants are leaking into the house.
That same release says homeowners should not service fuel-burning appliances themselves, and names a qualified plumber, heating contractor or gas company technician as the people to inspect them yearly. A chimney sweep is the other obvious candidate for the flue itself, and the two jobs fit together: the heating contractor tunes the burner and the sweep looks at where its exhaust goes. If your service visit ends at the furnace cabinet, the chimney has not been inspected.
How many Pennsylvania homes does this concern?
Most of them burn gas or oil. The Census Bureau estimates that gas is the main heating fuel in 56.4 percent of occupied homes in Pennsylvania and fuel oil or kerosene in another 14.0 percent. The mix shifts across the Philadelphia area. In Bucks County oil heats 23.6 percent of homes, and in Philadelphia gas heats 71.3 percent and oil only 2.7 percent.
One limit applies to those figures. They count fuel, not chimneys, so they do not show how many of these appliances vent into one. Look at where the metal pipe from your furnace or water heater goes. If it enters the brick, this guide is about your house. Philadelphia's own gas utility puts the advice in one line: have your appliances, chimney and flue serviced regularly by a qualified technician.
What might an inspection lead to?
It may end with nothing more than a cleaned flue. When a liner has corroded, or the flue is the wrong size for a newer appliance, the repair is to the liner, and chimney liners explains the types and the published prices.
The health side of all this is in carbon monoxide and your chimney, including where alarms belong, and how often a chimney should be swept gives the schedule for every kind of flue. Businesses that inspect furnace chimneys are on the chimney sweeps directory page.
Sources
- Homeowner Resources, Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA)
- Avoiding Carbon Monoxide Hazards, Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA)
- Carbon Monoxide (CO) Poisoning Basics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Carbon Monoxide's Impact on Indoor Air Quality, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- Inspect Home Furnace System For Hazards, Carbon Monoxide, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
- CPSC Urges Annual Fuel-Burning Appliance Inspection to Prevent Deaths, Fires, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
- Install a carbon monoxide alarm in your home: CPSC Urges Annual Furnace Inspection to Prevent CO Deaths, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
- Carbon Monoxide Questions and Answers, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
- BBB Tip: Hiring a chimney sweep, Better Business Bureau
- How much does it cost to have a chimney cleaned?, Fixr
- 2020-2024 ACS 5-Year Narrative Profile: Pennsylvania, U.S. Census Bureau
- 2020-2024 ACS 5-Year Narrative Profile: Bucks County, Pennsylvania, U.S. Census Bureau
- 2020-2024 ACS 5-Year Narrative Profile: Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, U.S. Census Bureau
- Natural Gas Safety, Philadelphia Gas Works