How often should trees be pruned or inspected, and what is the best time of year?
Updated · KeystoneProGuide editorial team
How often does a mature tree need pruning?
Less often than many people assume. Penn State Extension says a mature tree that has had its needs met throughout its life should only need pruning for specific purposes, such as managing risk, keeping branches clear of buildings and lines, or repairing storm damage. It suggests that many mature trees may benefit from a yearly inspection "with perhaps a five- to 10-year cycle of pruning", and warns that pruning a mature tree too much or incorrectly can cause more harm than good, because every live branch removed reduces the tree's food production and every cut is an opening for decay.
The International Society of Arboriculture makes the same point more briefly: "no branch should be cut without a reason."
How often should a tree be inspected?
Penn State suggests a yearly inspection for many mature trees, and a look after every major storm. Its advice to shade tree commissions describes when to look. An early spring inspection, before the leaves come out, shows dead, broken and defective branches most clearly. A follow-up in late summer helps tell live branches, which are in leaf, from dead ones. And a look after summer thunderstorms or winter ice finds broken branches caught in the canopy, which can fall without warning weeks later.
If a tree has been cabled or braced, ISA says the hardware must be inspected regularly. What to look for on each visit is in signs a tree needs an arborist.
How often do young trees need pruning?
More often, but lightly. Penn State recommends training a young tree over several years to correct its structure. At planting, it says to prune only broken, malformed or diseased branches, because excessive pruning can delay a new tree's normal growth and establishment. About two or three years after planting, it suggests a closer look to choose the branches the tree will keep for life. Keeping wounds small means removing branches before they are more than 1 inch in diameter.
What is the best time of year to prune?
For most trees, before the new growth starts in spring. ISA says growth and wound closure are maximized if pruning takes place before the spring growth flush, and that heavy pruning of live wood just after the spring flush should be avoided, especially on weak trees. It adds that most light, routine pruning to remove weak, dead or diseased limbs can be done at any time of year with little effect on the tree.
For young trees, Penn State says to avoid pruning from bud break until the leaves are fully out, and again as the tree goes dormant in fall, then to resume once it is dormant.
There are exceptions:
- Oaks. ISA says susceptible trees should not be pruned during the active transmission period of diseases such as oak wilt, which can spread through pruning wounds. Penn State's Master Gardeners say qualified arborists prune oaks only in winter, apart from emergency repairs, because fresh cuts in warmer months attract the sap beetles that carry the disease.
- Flowering trees. Penn State says to prune hawthorns, crabapples, pears and other flowering trees immediately after they flower.
Is there a cheaper season?
The sources suggest so. Penn State says to try to schedule tree work in fall or winter, "when rates may drop", and the cost site Angi says winter can save up to 20 percent on tree and stump work. The ranges themselves are in what tree work costs.
How often does the utility trim near the lines?
On its own schedule. A Public Utility Commission regulation sets a statewide minimum inspection and treatment cycle of 4 to 8 years for vegetation near distribution lines, and PECO says its routine cycles are four years long, with some mid-cycle work on fast-growing trees. That covers the lines on poles, not the wire to your house.
When should pest treatments be timed?
Before the damage, as a rule.
- Emerald ash borer. The Department of Conservation and Natural Resources says insecticide applications should begin before your ash tree is attacked.
- Hemlock woolly adelgid. The department says systemic insecticides can prevent new infestations for up to five to seven years.
- Spotted lanternfly. Penn State says egg masses can be found from September through June and adults from July until late December. It says soil drenches work best in early summer on trees that had high numbers before, should go on after a tree's flowers have faded, and that no insecticide should ever be sprayed on blooming plants. It also says not every tree in an infested area needs treating.
What is a sensible routine?
Put together, the official advice suggests a simple pattern for a house with large trees: a careful look each spring before leaf-out and after big storms, professional pruning only when there is a reason for it, oaks and other disease-prone trees left for winter, and pest treatment planned before an infestation rather than after. Businesses that serve your area are on the tree services directory page.
Sources
- Pruning Landscape Trees, Penn State Extension
- Dealing with Tree Risk: Tips for Municipal Shade Tree Commissions, Penn State Extension
- When to Call an Arborist, Penn State Extension (Allegheny County Master Gardeners)
- Pruning Trees, International Society of Arboriculture (TreesAreGood.org)
- Managing Hazards and Risk, International Society of Arboriculture (TreesAreGood.org)
- Routine Maintenance Improves Reliability, PECO
- 52 Pa. Code 57.198. Inspection and maintenance standards, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (Pennsylvania Code)
- Stump Grinding Cost, Angi
- Agrilus planipennis (Emerald Ash Borer), Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources
- Adelges tsugae (Hemlock Woolly Adelgid), Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources
- Spotted Lanternfly Management Guide, Penn State Extension
- How You Can Comply with the Spotted Lanternfly Quarantine Regulations, Penn State Extension